Jay's Midlake serves an extensive menu, focusing on hearty, comfort food. The Pulled Pork Sandwich is immensely popular, complemented by a variety of sides like waffle fries and Wisconsin cheese curds.
The menu also features smoked chicken dishes and a selection of pizzas that cater to different tastes. Visitors appreciate the kids’ menu, making it family-friendly.
For those wanting a quick snack, sharing platters are available. With items like fried pickles and mushrooms, there's something for everyone. Seasonal drinks and local beers round out the meal, inviting guests to mingle while they dine. Every visit promises a satisfying meal worth craving.
Featured Dishes

Fish

Smoked Wings Plain

Pretzel Bites and Fried Cheese Curds

Wisconsin Cheese Curds

Egg and Pepper Jack Cheese on a Bun

Shrimp & Fries

Fried Onion Chips

blt Wrap with Fried Pickle Spears

Steak Hoagie with Pizza Sauce

Bacon Cheeseburger & Fries

Smoked pp

Patatas Bravas

Michelob
Welcome to Jays Midlake Bait.Tackle.Restaurant, your friendly neighborhood stop on the way to Brookville Lake! As a family-run establishment, we take pride in serving delicious, locally-inspired dishes like our year-round Pulled Pork and seasonal Smoked Chicken Salad, crafted from our own recipe and smoked right here. Whether you're looking to fuel up before your fishing adventure or simply enjoy the cozy atmosphere, we’re excited to welcome you. With a great selection of beers, cocktails, and quick service, we're the perfect spot for lunch, dinner, or a relaxing solo meal. Come and taste the love!